To the OP,

I've never used eye tape but my mom has way back then. And in all honesty, makeup doesnt go very well over it. Will makeup stick on tape? Certainly not. It's plastic...

There are other types of tapes too.. some are more ... how can i explain it.... more gauzy-like? Like a rougher pore-d surface... that would hold makeup a little better but you can't do any closed eyes shots because you will see the tape.

Hope this answers your question.